When New York Yankees starting pitcher Andy Pettitte retired at the beginning of last month, he left some of his fans yearning for a great comeback one day. Too bad celebrities such as Lindsay Lohan and Charlie Sheen aren’t likely to find themselves in the same boat.
Too bad that in many areas of business — not just marketing or advertising — it’s all too tempting to ride a wave out for as long as we’re able, even when it may make more sense to quit while we’re ahead.
Remember how the GEICO cavemen took the U.S. by storm back in 2004 with all those funny TV commercials? Well, that was a very different scenario from the one they find themselves in today with a failed 2007 ABC sitcom and an unexceptional vlog and social networking site presence. And now we have the hunky, wildly popular Old Spice spokesman Isaiah Mustafa. Over the past eight months or so, he has delighted the American consumer and breathed new life into the Old Spice brand. But when will it be time for Isaiah to throw in the towel? (sorry, couldn’t resist the pun)
It’s not an easy question to answer. Wait too long and risk losing the consumer’s interest. Get out too early and miss a great opportunity to further strengthen and grow the brand. I’m sure executives over at Rovio Mobile wish they had a crystal ball as they take their hit mobile game Angry Birds and venture out into toys, board games, and possibly even movies.
Photo credit: Larry Ewing

